How to Make Crushed Tomatoes

Have an overabundance of garden tomatoes? It only takes a few easy steps to make fresh homemade crushed tomatoes with your garden haul!

This post may contain affiliate links.  Making a purchase through one of these links helps support this blog.

Jar of fresh garden crushed tomatoes with spoon in jar. Jar sits on wooden board with fresh basil and tomatoes.

One of our large tomato plants is starting to slow down for the season.  There are bunches of green tomatoes on each branch, but they're taking longer to mature.  Our other tomato plant is still producing mature fruit on a daily basis.  It's been hard to keep up!

I recently read an article in the September issue of Martha Stewart Living about making your garden tomatoes last after the summer.  The article shared a few ways to do so.  One of which was making your own crushed tomato sauce to either can or freeze.

Numerous fresh garden tomatoes.

We use crushed tomatoes in so many of our meals!  Crushed tomatoes make an excellent pasta sauce base.  We also use them to make our own pizza sauce, add to homemade chili, and stir into tomato soup.  Honestly, we usually keep a stash of cans on hand because they end up in so many different recipes!

How to Make Crushed Tomatoes

If you have an overabundance of tomatoes still growing in your garden, making your own crushed tomato sauce is super easy!  It just takes a few simple steps.  After, you can prepare jars for canning or store it in freezer bags or container for future use.

Tomatoes scored on the bottom and boiled in a pot of water.

Score an "x" on the bottom of each tomato.  Bring a large pot of water to a boil.

Then, boil the tomatoes until the skin starts to separate from the fruit.  This will only take a few minutes.  You'll notice the tomato skin start to wrinkle.

Tomatoes in a large bowl of ice water.

Once boiled, place the tomatoes into a large bowl of ice water.  Allow them to cool completely or until cool enough to handle.

Tomatoes with skin removed.

Now, you should be able to peel the skin away from the tomatoes easily.  Discard the skin and place tomatoes into your blender or food processor.  Pulse until smooth.

Bowl of tomatoes being blended with an immersion blender.

Alternately, you could use an immersion blender.  I actually prefer this method.  Add the tomatoes to a large bowl and use the blender to blend the tomatoes until smooth.

Top view of fresh homemade garden crushed tomatoes. Jar sits on top of a wooden board with fresh basil and tomatoes.

Pour sauce into freezer-safe bags and/or containers.  The sauce will keep in the freezer for up to three months.

How to Make Crushed Tomatoes

Have an overabundance of garden tomatoes? It only takes a few easy steps to make fresh homemade crushed tomatoes with your garden haul!
Author Jessica

Ingredients

  • Fresh tomatoes
  • Water
  • Ice water

Instructions

  • Score an "x" onto the bottom of each tomato.
  • Bring a large pot of water to a boil. Carefully place tomatoes into the pot. Boil until skin starts to peel away.
  • When ready, place tomatoes into large bowl of ice water. Cool completely.
  • Peel the tomatoes and discard the skin. Place the tomatoes into a blender. Pulse until smooth.
  • Alternately, place tomatoes into a large bowl and use an immersion blender to blend tomatoes until smooth.
  • Pour sauce into freezer-safe jars or freezer bags. Keep in freezer up to three months.

Close up photo of homemade garden crushed tomatoes in jar with spoon. Jar sits on wooden board with fresh basil and tomatoes.

I'll never knock canned tomatoes, but it's always nice to know exactly what's going into your meal and where it came from.  Now that you have homemade garden crushed tomatoes, check out these 11 Recipes You Can Make with Tomato Sauce!

Did you make this recipe? Share it on social media using the hashtag #holokahome. Don’t forget to tag me @holokahome!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating